Now, if you ever been in the kitchen and wondered how to make a real good butterscotch pudding, well, let me tell you, it’s not that hard. I ain’t no fancy chef, but I’ve been makin’ this for years and it’s one of them desserts that’ll make your mouth water. You see, it’s all about that sweet, buttery taste, and it ain’t like them box mixes folks buy. Nope, this here’s the real deal. You cook it from scratch, and that makes all the difference.

What Makes Butterscotch Pudding So Special?
Now, what’s so special about butterscotch pudding, you ask? Well, it’s the taste. You know how some puddings are all runny and thin? That ain’t this kind! When you make it from scratch, you cook brown sugar and butter together ’til it gets all bubbly, like a little caramel but with brown sugar instead of that white kind. Once it’s bubbling good, you add in some heavy cream, and that’s when it starts looking like something you’d want to eat. Don’t forget to keep stirring, ’cause if you don’t, it’ll burn right up on ya!
And let me tell ya, the key to a good, thick pudding is that cornstarch. You gotta bring it to a good, strong boil to make sure it sets. Otherwise, you’ll end up with some sad, thin stuff, and that just won’t do.
How to Make Butterscotch Pudding?
Now, let’s get to the making part. Here’s how I do it:

- First, you’ll need some brown sugar and butter. About a half cup of brown sugar and a good tablespoon of butter is what I use.
- Heat that up in a pot ’til it starts bubbling. Keep an eye on it, ‘cause you don’t want it burning, just bubbling real good.
- Once it’s bubbling nice and slow, pour in about a cup of heavy cream. Stir it well, so everything mixes together smooth.
- Next, you’ll add in some cornstarch. About two tablespoons will do. This is what makes it thicken up.
- Now, let it boil good for a few minutes, keep stirring so it don’t stick to the bottom of the pan. Once it thickens up to where it’s nice and creamy, take it off the heat.
Now, you can pour it into bowls and let it cool down. Some folks like to put it in the fridge for a little while, but I don’t mind eating it warm either. It’s all good, you know?
What to Pair With Butterscotch Pudding?
Butterscotch pudding don’t have to be plain, though. You can add all sorts of stuff to make it your own. You could mix in some vanilla, cinnamon, or even a little salted caramel. If you’re feelin’ fancy, try adding maple or banana flavor. Heck, even a little coffee wouldn’t hurt. If you’re watchin’ your calories, there’s always them sugar-free syrups or flavored extracts. Just a little drop will give it a good flavor without all the sugar, and still keep it tasty.
Tips for the Perfect Butterscotch Pudding
- Don’t rush it: You gotta make sure that sugar and butter melt down nice and slow. If you cook it too fast, it’ll burn and that ain’t what you’re lookin’ for.
- Use heavy cream: If you want that creamy, rich texture, don’t go skimpin’ on the cream. It’s what makes it taste so good.
- Stir constantly: If you don’t stir it, the pudding will burn at the bottom and nobody likes that. Keep at it!
- Let it cool: Once you take it off the heat, let it cool down for a few minutes before you start eatin’ it. If you try to eat it right off the stove, it might burn your tongue, and that ain’t no fun.
Conclusion

So, there you have it. A simple butterscotch pudding recipe that’s rich, creamy, and just the right amount of sweetness. You can make it fancy or keep it plain, but I promise you, once you’ve made it from scratch, you ain’t gonna want no store-bought stuff again. It’s perfect for a little treat after supper, or to impress folks when they come over for a visit. So get to cookin’, and enjoy that puddin’!
Tags:[butterscotch pudding, homemade pudding, desserts, easy pudding recipe, creamy desserts, butterscotch recipes, sweet pudding, rich dessert]