Well now, let me tell ya somethin’ about this here peanut butter fudge. If ya ever thought making somethin’ sweet was all fuss and bother, then this recipe is gonna change yer mind! This peanut butter fudge, it only takes two things, two ingredients, mind ya! Don’t need all them fancy things they talk about on TV. Nope, just peanut butter and one more thing, and you’re all set!

Now, the first thing ya need is a good ol’ jar of peanut butter. I reckon you don’t want to be using that natural peanut butter, the kind that comes with oil on top. If ya use that, the fudge might not come out right. That oil can get all funny and separate on ya, and you don’t want that mess in yer fudge. Stick to the smooth kind, creamy peanut butter. The kind that stays all together and doesn’t make a fuss. You know, the kind that sticks to your teeth and gets all gooey, but in a good way! So, get ya some creamy peanut butter, and make sure it’s the kind that comes smooth and ready to go.
Now, for the second ingredient. You might think you need chocolate, or sugar, or all sorts of other things, but nope! You just need some sweetened condensed milk. This is the magic that holds everything together. It’s thick, sweet, and makes everything just come together in the most perfect way. If ya don’t have condensed milk, then, well, yer fudge just ain’t gonna turn out like it should. I ain’t kiddin’ ya. It’s like the glue that sticks it all together. Get yourself a can of that stuff, and make sure you get the sweetened kind! Don’t be messin’ with unsweetened stuff, unless ya want to ruin the whole batch.
Now, listen close, ’cause I’m gonna tell ya how to put it all together. First off, ya take about 16 ounces of that peanut butter. You pour it into a bowl. Ain’t gotta be fancy, just a regular ol’ mixing bowl will do. Then, you take your sweetened condensed milk—usually a whole can, about 14 ounces—and you pour it right into the bowl with the peanut butter. Now, I know what you’re thinkin’—you might think it’s too sweet, but trust me, it’s just right!
Once you got both them ingredients in the bowl, you’re gonna wanna mix ‘em together. Don’t rush it now! Stir it slow, nice and steady. The peanut butter and the milk are gonna blend into a nice, smooth mixture. You want it to be all creamy and soft. Now, I’d say this might take a couple minutes, but once it’s all mixed up real good, it’s time to put it in a pan. Get yourself a baking pan—doesn’t matter the size too much, but I’d say 8×8 works just fine—and line it with some parchment paper, or if you ain’t got that, grease it up with a little butter. Pour your fudge mixture into the pan and spread it out nice and even. Just press it down gently with the back of a spoon.
Now, here’s the trick that most people forget: you gotta let that fudge cool down and harden up. Don’t try to rush it! Put that pan in the fridge and leave it there for a few hours, or overnight if ya got the patience. You don’t want to be messin’ with it too soon, or it won’t set up proper. When it’s all cool and firm, you can cut it into little squares, and there ya go, you got yourself some homemade peanut butter fudge! Ain’t that easy?

I tell ya, this here fudge is so good, nobody’ll even know how simple it was to make. They’ll be askin’ ya for the recipe, and you can just smile and say, “Oh, just two ingredients.” They won’t believe it, but it’s the truth. It’s rich, it’s creamy, and it’s downright delicious. Ain’t no need for all them fancy ingredients, just keep it simple and sweet.
Now, if yer wonderin’ why yer fudge ain’t hardenin’ up right, well, there’s a couple things that might be goin’ on. First, make sure you let it cool all the way, like I said. Sometimes folks get in a hurry and try to rush it. Don’t do that! If yer fudge is still soft, it might not have been heated right when you mixed it. So make sure you’re stirrin’ everything real good and let it set in the fridge long enough. Patience is key, ya see!
So there you have it. Two ingredients, some patience, and in no time at all, you got yourself a treat that’ll make everybody think you spent hours in the kitchen, when really, it was just a few simple steps. Hope y’all enjoy this here fudge recipe. It’s a real keeper, I tell ya!
Tags:[2 Ingredient Peanut Butter Fudge, Easy Peanut Butter Fudge, Quick Fudge Recipe, Peanut Butter Fudge, Simple Fudge Recipe, Homemade Peanut Butter Fudge, Easy Fudge, No-Bake Fudge Recipe]