Alright, so St. Patrick’s Day is rolling around again. Usually, I’m all about the regular festive treats, but this year I decided to try something different. My sister’s been eating gluten-free for a while now, and I figured it’d be nice to make something everyone could actually enjoy together. Plus, honestly, I was curious how hard it would be.
Getting Started and Gathering Stuff
First thing I did was hit the internet, looking for ideas. You type in “gluten-free St. Patrick’s desserts” and wow, a lot comes up. Some looked way too complicated, needing weird ingredients I’d never heard of. I wanted something straightforward. I settled on trying two things: some simple mint chocolate chip cookies and maybe some kind of green brownie or blondie.

Next step was the grocery store. Finding the gluten-free flour blend wasn’t too bad these days, most bigger stores have a decent section. I grabbed one that said it was a cup-for-cup replacement, hoping that would make things easier. Also needed xanthan gum – heard that helps hold gluten-free stuff together. Got my usual butter, sugar, eggs, plus some peppermint extract and, of course, green food coloring. I opted for the simple liquid drops, nothing fancy.
Into the Kitchen We Go
I decided to tackle the cookies first. The recipe seemed easy enough. I creamed the butter and sugar, added the eggs and peppermint extract. Then came the gluten-free flour mix. This is where things felt different. The dough seemed…grittier? Less stretchy than normal cookie dough. I mixed in the chocolate chips and a few drops of green coloring. It looked the part, at least.
Scooping them onto the baking sheet was okay, maybe a little stickier than I’m used to. Popped them in the oven, keeping a close eye on them. Gluten-free things can sometimes bake faster or slower, I’ve heard.
While the cookies baked, I started on the brownies. Found a recipe for gluten-free blondies that I figured I could just dye green and add mint to. Again, mixing the wet ingredients was fine. Adding the GF flour blend… same deal. The batter felt denser. I added the green dye – maybe a bit too much, it looked intensely green! Stirred in some chopped chocolate.
The Results and What I Learned
Okay, the cookies came out of the oven. They spread a bit more than I expected, looking a little flat. Taste test? Surprisingly good! Nice minty flavor, decent texture, maybe slightly crumblier than a regular cookie, but definitely enjoyable. Success number one, I’d say.
Then the brownies, or greenies, I guess. They took a bit longer to bake than the recipe suggested. The toothpick test was tricky; it kept coming out a bit wet in the middle. I eventually pulled them out, hoping for the best. Letting them cool was important.
Cutting into the greenies… they were very fudgy. Almost too fudgy in the center. The taste was good, minty and sweet, but the texture was a bit off, very dense. Not bad, but not quite the chewy brownie I was aiming for. Maybe I should have adjusted the liquid or baking time more.

So, what did I learn? Gluten-free baking isn’t scary, but it’s definitely different. The texture is the main thing. You can’t just swap flour and expect the exact same result without potentially needing other small tweaks. The cup-for-cup flour was helpful, but maybe next time I’d research specific flour blends for brownies versus cookies. Also, trust your gut on baking times, not just the recipe.
Overall, it was a fun experiment. We had green, gluten-free treats for St. Paddy’s, and my sister was happy she could dig in. Definitely worth trying if you need GF options for a gathering.