The Price Tag Shock
I walked into that supplement store last Tuesday, feeling all pumped about getting healthier. Then I saw it: Vital Cuisine Mighty Shakes priced at $65 for a 10-day supply. My wallet straight up cried. Who’s got that kinda cash to drop on milkshakes every month? Not this guy.
First Failed Attempt
Tried the obvious first – hunted for coupons like a maniac. Scrolled through 15 coupon sites till my eyes crossed. Found squat. Then emailed customer service begging for discounts. They sent back this auto-reply nonsense about “premium quality pricing.” Yeah right.

The Kitchen Experiment
Grabbed my blender next morning and went full mad scientist:
- Dumped whey protein from Costco ($0.80/serving)
- Threw in frozen spinach & bananas ($0.30)
- Added cheap flax seeds ($0.10)
- Mixed with tap water ($free)
Total damage? $1.20 per shake. Tasted like grass clippings first try. Nearly puked.
Flavor Tweaking
Watched 7 YouTube tutorials about flavor masking. Learned two game-changers:
- Add cinnamon to kill veggie aftertaste
- Freeze berries first to skip ice cubes
Third batch actually didn’t suck. Kids tried it and didn’t scream – that’s victory.
Monthly Savings Breakdown
Pulled out the calculator:

- Before: $195/month for Vital Cuisine
- Now: $36/month DIY
That’s $159 saved every 30 days. Put that cash towards my kid’s college fund instead.
The Real Win
Turns out my cheap shakes work better for weight loss anyway. Why? Cause I control the sugar. Those “mighty” store shakes? Packed with hidden sweeteners that spike insulin. My wallet’s fatter and my pants fit looser. Double victory dance.